The median home in Fire Island Pines, New York is valued at $1,319,872, up 9.8% year over year. Fire Island Pines is part of the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ-PA metropolitan area, which CrashWatch tracks daily with real-time stress scores and crash risk analysis.

Home Value$1,319,872

+9.8%

Prices rising — worse for buyers.

Affordability

Enter your income for Fire Island Pines.

Income (annual)

Down Payment

$263,974 on $1,319,872

Example: $75,000 household income. Change it above to see your own.

Out of reach139.5% of income

Need $373,543/yr to afford.

PITI$8,716

P/I139.5%

Afford$265K

Gap-$1.05M

P&I $6,674Tax $1,892Ins $150

6.50% 30yr, 20% down, county tax + NY ins. 28% per HUD.

Home Buying Kit For Dummies (2025)Financing, negotiation, closing

Other cities in New York

Compare Fire Island Pines with other housing markets across New York.

Sagaponack$7.21M Water Mill$4.54M Bridgehampton$4.44M Wainscott$3.78M Sands Point$3.18M Amagansett$2.97M Old Westbury$2.85M Quogue$2.77M

Full New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ-PA analysis

Stress scores, crash risk, early warning signals, and 12-month price forecasts for the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ-PA metro.

View New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ-PA metro

Weekly briefing

Every Monday — score changes, top movers, and what shifted. Free.

Fire Island Pines, NY